https://www.academia.edu/181406593/When_is_Life_Grievable_War_and_Mourning_in_Ancient_Egypt?email_work_card=title
This paper examines the motif of foreign grief in ancient Egyptian battle representations and juxtaposes it with the absence of public commemorative monuments to fallen Egyptian soldiers. From the Old Kingdom through the New Kingdom, battle scenes in private tombs and temples regularly included images of grieving foreign noncombatants, such as women, the elderly, and children. Although violence against foreign women and children is not visually represented during the New Kingdom, the traumatic experiences associated with the loss of members of their communities become an essential component of battle scenes. At the same time, textual records and visual representations of war in ancient Egypt remain largely silent about Egyptian losses and avoid depicting Egyptian soldiers as victims of wartime violence. This discrepancy can be explained as a consequence of an ideology that attributed to men the duty of caring for and protecting the vulnerable. By portraying foreign women, the elderly, and children as grieving, Egyptian artists emphasized the failure of foreign men to provide care and protection for those under their responsibility. This perspective may also explain the absence of commemorative monuments for Egyptian men who died in war, since such monuments would imply that they failed to return home and fulfil their role as protectors of their own vulnerable.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario