viernes, 14 de octubre de 2016

MercatorNet: Why Bob Dylan is a Nobel choice [ONLY FOR THOUGHT - NEW SECTION OF LOST IDEAS] while adding value

MercatorNet: Why Bob Dylan is a Nobel choice

Why Bob Dylan is a Nobel choice

Why Bob Dylan is a Nobel choice

Of course it's literature. Of the highest order.
Martin Fitzgerald | Oct 14 2016 | comment 

I was lucky. I came to Bob Dylan after the 1960s.
I came to him without the weight of his being “the prophet of a generation”. It wasn’t Masters of War, Blowin’ in the Wind, or even The Times they are a Changin’  that grabbed me.  
It was songs like It Ain’t Me Babe,
You say you're lookin' for someone
Who's never weak but always strong
To protect you an' defend you
Whether you are right or wrong
Someone to open each and every door
But it ain't me, babe
You say you're looking for someone
Who'll pick you up each time you fall
To gather flowers constantly
An' to come each time you call
A lover for your life an' nothing more
But it ain't me, babe
This was an anti-love song: one about someone who was OK with saying that all the ideal male traits of romantic songs, films, books and advertisements in the 1950s was impossible for him. And I found out later when I studied Browning at University that it had the literary form of a dramatic monologue.
Then came Blood on the Tracks in 1975, the album that many regard as Dylan’s best. Here was mature heartbreak. Two people in Idiot Wind who once loved each other can no longer even be near each other;
In order to get in a word with youI’da had to make up some excuse,  It just struck me kinda funny.
That’s where it all started and it has not stopped.
Nice, even clever, lines you might say but is he a worthy winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature? I say yes. The news of the Prize has split the literary world. Some think it is a joke. Others have tried to justify it.  Journalists have been at pains to point out that some experts think his words divested of music and put down on paper hold their own as literature.
Sara Danius, a literary scholar and the permanent secretary of the 18-member academy, called Dylan “a great poet in the English-speaking tradition” and compared him to Homer and Sappho, whose work was delivered orally.
In fact, Dylan’s work is far more literary than most of his fans realise, with echoes of the greats of the Western Canon floating through his lyrics. Christopher Ricks, a professor at Boston University, believes that Dylan is "the greatest living user of the English language" and compares him with Tennyson, Milton, Wordsworth, Eliot, and, he says, "that Dylanesque writer, William Shakespeare." He’s not alone. Dylan has been nominated for the Nobel Prize every year since 1996.
In any case, since when does genius have to be confined to conventional forms and categories, like cereal boxes on a supermarket shelf?
But I’ve always felt that there is no need to justify Dylan’s work on the basis that it is just as good as “normal poetry”. The citation of the Swedish Academy says that Dylan received the award for “having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition.”
There is no question about this. Dylan created new poetic expressions with a guitar slung over his shoulder and a harmonica harness around his neck. While purists see poetry and songwriting as two different things, the modern world has brought them together. There is no way Dylan could have received this Prize in any other time but our own.
He belongs to the era of the mass production of recorded music, to the era of the radio, the television and a huge music industry. This made his music accessible to just about everyone, at first in the affluent West and now, in just about every corner of the world. This had never happened before in the history of humanity.
Dylan’s muse and inspiration, Woody Guthrie, would never have been able to have the mass audience that Dylan has. He lived too early. The reach of Dylan’s work is what has made it possible for him to contribute “new forms of poetic expression to the history of songwriting in America”.  
He dragged the folk songs which Guthrie wrote out of the dustbowl of America and threw them in the faces of people who didn’t like to think the American Dream contained pockets of disadvantage and at times misery.
He transmitted the anti-establishment message of the early folk recording artists to more people than Guthrie could every dream of. He brought the disadvantage and the exploitation to the attention of more people than Steinbeck could ever have done.
And then, when everyone thought they had him figured out, he plugged his guitar in and belted out songs about princesses in steeples - rich, girls who are so pampered they would not know what to do if they were stripped of their expensive education, their fashion and connections to politicians and had to confront tramps in the street. What would they feel like, if they were just rolling stones? And is this not the same question we are asked in Lord of the Flies? What becomes of us when we are stripped of our civilization? 
Do the questions lose their power if they are posed about society girls in a song and not about English boarding school boys in a novel? Over the decades Dylan changed his style and themes again and agains. The sheer variety and volume of his songs is overwhelming. And that's another sign of literary greatness -- constantly renewed creativity. 
The artists who take up residence in the collective consciousness are often breakers of moulds: new voices for a new age. Dylan has thrilled millions upon millions of people, giving voice to their frustration, sadness, joy and dreams. It’s about time that the Nobel Prize descended from Olympus. Dylan is an inspired choice.
Martin Fitzgerald is a teacher at Redfield College, in Sydney.MercatorNet
I would like to issue a big thank-you to the Swedes for giving Bob Dylan the Nobel Prize in Literature. Thank God we have something to argue about this week other than the failings of Donald Trump.

I’ve noticed that reactions to the news varied according to the age of the pundit. The baby-boomers are swooning. Dylan is, after all, the guardian angel of baby-boomerdom – rebellion, nostalgia, confusion, and anxiety. He captured the Zeitgeist.
But I’ve noticed that millennial critics tended to say: “Dylan, what the…? He writes songs, not poetry?! They don’t make sense without the music.” It’s odd that Dylan’s trademark surrealism and protest don’t strike a chord with a younger generation.
Anyhow, a bit like the Nobel Peace Prize, which Al Gore won for his PowerPoint skills and Barack Obama for nothing at all, the Nobel Prize in Literature is meant to provoke controversy. Let it begin. Read Martin Fitzgerald’s reaction below

Michael Cook 

Why Bob Dylan is a Nobel choice

By Martin Fitzgerald
Of course it's literature. Of the highest order.

Read the full article
In honouring Dylan, the judges have made a category error

By Jen Webb
The greatest living poet? Not on your nelly.

Read the full article
King Harold the Great: if the English had beaten the Normans in 1066

By Charles West and Alyxandra Mattison
950 years ago today, the last successful invasion of England took place

Read the full article
Your kids and the facts of life, Part 2

By Carolyn Smith and Mary Cooney
An experienced mother offers great advice

Read the full article
Transgender identities are not always permanent

By Walt Heyer
A man who lived as a woman for years shares his traumatic experience

Read the full article
Some thoughts on marriage from young Chinese

By Marcus Roberts
An insight perhaps into why marriage is declining in China.

Read the full article
Dracula’s daughter takes on the Ottoman Empire

By Jennifer Minicus
Yet another young adult novel full of sex and violence

Read the full article
As medicine improves, how long can we expect to live?

By Karl D. Stephan
We seem to have a built-in expiration date of about 115 years

Read the full article
All the boxes have been ticked, but single career women are still not happy

By Julia Vidmar
Today's young women are over-achievers and the young men are under-achievers.

Read the full article
Siblings with benefits

By Tamara El-Rahi
A little gratitude for my siblings as I settle into motherhood.

Read the full article
MERCATORNET | New Media Foundation 
Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George Street, North Strathfied NSW 2137, Australia 

Designed by elleston
New Media Foundation | Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605 

No hay comentarios: