lunes, 20 de febrero de 2017

Pre-Reformation church music: plainchant, polyphony and popular songs | MercatorNet

Pre-Reformation church music: plainchant, polyphony and popular songs

Pre-Reformation church music: plainchant, polyphony and popular songs

Pre-Reformation church music: plainchant, polyphony and popular songs

A passionate debate about liturgical music raged at the beginning of the 16th century.
Chiara Bertoglio | Feb 20 2017 | comment 

This is the second of an occasional series by Italian musician and theologian Chiara Bertoglio on the musical history of the Reformation which began with Martin Luther in 1517.
Music was an essential component of life in the early-modern era, at all levels of culture, wealth or literacy. In this article I will briefly discuss how music entered into and impacted the daily, cultural and social life of the time. In particular, it will be necessary – in order to frame the discussion which will follow in the subsequent articles – to understand the intellectual and cultural view of music, and how it dovetailed with the spiritual concerns which will eventually give momentum to the Reformations.
In church, plainchant constituted a red thread, since it was sung in the rural parish churches as well as in the most important cathedrals. In the greatest abbeys or basilicas, however, professional choirs regularly offered performances of the polyphonic masterpieces written by the great Franco-Flemish composers, such as Josquin Des Prez, or by those who had mastered the technique and style perfected within that context.
The uneducated -- the peasants, but also the illiterate inhabitants of the cities – for their part would sing religious or devotional songs in the vernacular. These formed the soundtrack of daily life: while easing the fatigue of manual labour, of repetitive tasks, of long journeys frequently undertaken by foot, these pious songs also gave a deeply religious – indeed, theological -- meaning to the dull, tiring or painful aspects of life.
Of course, while these songs expressed in a genuine fashion the spiritual life of many people throughout Europe, they were frequently less theologically precise and reliable than their liturgical counterparts. This happens also today, when “spiritual songs” may become very popular in the mainstream market, without always finding a space within the framework of Sunday worship, at least in the traditional churches.
The debate regarding what kind of music was suited for the official Catholic worship at the beginning of the 16th century was heated and passionate. Tradition had built a large repertoire of sacred songs, mostly in Latin; some of them had a Biblical source (as Psalms and canticles), others could boast important authorships (as, for example, the hymns written by St Ambrose, some of which are still in use today). Sequences had proliferated almost uncontrollably, and there were so many of them (about 2,000-3,000) that it was virtually impossible to verify their theological soundness and their spiritual quality.
Classical and patristic influences
The early 16th century was also a moment when the harvest of the humanist movement and thought was ripe. Humanism  had also contributed to the rediscovery of both classical (pagan) sources and of the Christian heritage of the Patristic writings. The theories of philosophers such as Plato or Aristotle, who forcefully maintained that music had a fundamental role in the education of a civil and peaceful society, were widely circulated. They were juxtaposed to the writings of Quintilian, who pointed out the rhetorical role of music for persuading and for “moving” the soul.
In turn, these “pagan” writers had been already commented upon by the early Christian essayists: St. Basil, for example, had written at length about the importance of Psalm-singing for creating a loving community of believers, for strengthening the faith of its younger or “weaker” members, and for spreading within society as a whole the good seed of the Gospel.
St. Augustine had expounded his thought on music on a variety of occasions. His stance was complex and controversial, and would be extremely influential for most reformers of the sixteenth century (also because Luther himself had been an Augustinian monk before leaving the Catholic Church).
On the one hand, Augustine celebrated the beauty of music, its capacity to elevate, to enchant, to amaze and to conquer believers’ hearts for God. He maintained that the summit of prayer, the moment when a soul is mystically enraptured with the contemplation of God, cannot be expressed in words: only “jubilation” (i.e. a song without words) could be adequate for such moments of pure joy.
On the other hand, however, and precisely because he was so conscious of the power of music, Augustine was not unconditionally supportive of music. He saw music as similar to love: both are God-given gifts which help the human beings to reach holiness and give them joy, but both can also become dangerous, negative and pernicious, when they are wrongly oriented.
In more recent times, Aquinas had discussed the role of (liturgical) music in his Summa Theologiae among other places. Here he had summarised the main pros and cons of church music, and he had started to raise a problem which would become more and more crucial as time went by. Was it licit, he asked, for the celebrating priests to sing? While some present-day churchgoers would be tempted to answer “no” (particularly when their pastors’ singing seems to become a divinely inflicted penance…), Thomas Aquinas argued that singing was a form of prayer which was suited for all believers.
Professional vs popular
This problem, in its artistic and social, but also in its theological and pastoral aspects was to resurface in the 16th century: as I wrote before, the beauty and complexity of the polyphonic masterpieces sung in the Renaissance era made it almost impossible for non-professionals to sing them. Thus, a double separation arose in the sung worship of the great churches: the celebrating priests did not sing (except plainchant when needed), the choir was made up of professional musicians who “performed” music rather than “prayed with song”, and the assembly or congregation simply “assisted” in a sung rite in which they did not participate vocally.
On most of these issues, the great philosopher Desiderius Erasmus of Rotterdam had his personal views. He had a high concept of music, though he complained about its excessive professionalisation: “In college or monastery”, he wrote, “it is still the same: music, nothing but music…”. On the other hand, however, he did not favour too much vocal participation by the congregation: in the early Church, he maintained, when all joined in singing, worship became a “thunderous noise and [a] ridiculous confusion”. Much better, he thought, if the non-musical laypeople simply sang “in their hearts”.
Erasmus was particularly critical of the English singers, who practised “ornamental neighings” with their “agile throats”, thus indulging “the whims of the foolish and […] their baser appetites”. In spite of this, he advocated a more widespread knowledge of Scripture, also by means of music: “would that […] the farmer sing some portion of [it] at the plough, the weaver hum some parts of them to the movement of his shuttle, the traveller lighten the weariness of the journey with stories of this kind!”.
We will see in subsequent articles how Erasmus’ wish was translated into reality by many religious reformers, and how his perplexities and criticism would be shared by others: if the Church was going to be deeply shaken in the following years, its music was going to experience drastic and troubling changes in turn, together with a fascinating blossoming of new artistic and spiritual works.
Dr Chiara Bertoglio is a musician, a musicologist and a theologian writing from Italy. She is particularly interested in the relationships between music and the Christian faith, and has written several books on this subject. Her new book, Reforming Music: Music and the Religious Reformations of the Sixteenth Century, is due to be published in April by De Gruyter. Visit her website
- See more at:


Norma McCorvey, who died on Saturday, was a celebrity whose very name is a household word. But she is better known as Jane Roe, the plaintiff in Roe v Wade, the 1973 case in which the Supreme Court effectively legalised abortion throughout the United States. Her lawyers told the court that Ms Roe wanted a safe and legal abortion and could not do so in the state of Texas. In fact, Ms McCorvey gave the child up for adoption. 
When Ms McCorvey came out of the shadows in the 1980s, it was as a fervent pro-choice advocate. She wrote an account of her unbearably sad early life, "I am Roe", in 1994, but, to the astonishment of both side in the abortion debate, only a year later she became a born-again Christian and a pro-life activist. It is an amazing story. Read Sheila Liaugminas's report below. 

Michael Cook 

‘The Great Wall’ fails to bring down the barriers in lacklustre Chinese-US epic
By Joyleen Christensen
The largest film ever shot entirely in China and the most expensive in the country’s history is a bit muddled.
Read the full article
Norma McCorvey’s death highlights Jane Roe’s conversion to life
By Sheila Liaugminas
She founded ‘Roe No More’ two decades ago to expose abortion lies.
Read the full article
Motherhood: the ideal vs reality
By Tamara El-Rahi
The chaos of children makes for a good life anyway.
Read the full article
Cities: life in the slow lane?
By Marcus Roberts
Researchers suggest that city dwellers have a "slow life strategy".
Read the full article
Pre-Reformation church music: plainchant, polyphony and popular songs
By Chiara Bertoglio
A passionate debate about liturgical music raged at the beginning of the 16th century.
Read the full article
Dear Warren: Contraception going well, newborn mortality not so well
By Carolyn Moynihan
Bill and Melinda Gates report on how they have been spending a philanthropic windfall.
Read the full article
Hacksaw Ridge
By Luisa Cotta Ramosino
A story of atypical heroism at the height of the Pacific war.
Read the full article
Somalia has a new president
By Mathew Otieno
He brings much needed hope to the battered nation.
Read the full article
After the exile: poetry and the death of culture
By Anthony Esolen
Who the heck is Spenser?
Read the full article
Which European countries have over 40% of their population migrating?
By Marcus Roberts
And which sends out the absolute largest number of migrants?
Read the full article
So many things
By J. Budziszewski
Young people are caught in a media mudslide that destroys intellectual depth.
Read the full article

MERCATORNET | New Media Foundation 
Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George Street, North Strathfied NSW 2137, Australia 

Designed by elleston

New Media Foundation | Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605 

No hay comentarios: